| Lake | County | Latitude | Longitude |
| P Lake | Erie | 42.982336 | -78.643878 |
| Pack Forest Lake | Warren | 43.557713 | -73.812602 |
| Paerdegat Basin | Kings | 40.617853 | -73.900711 |
| Paine Lake | Westchester | 40.935698 | -73.790577 |
| Papoose Lake | Franklin | 44.717494 | -74.127972 |
| Paradox Lake | Essex | 43.886035 | -73.692333 |
| Parsonage Cove | Nassau | 40.625752 | -73.608673 |
| Partlow Lake | Hamilton | 44.003528 | -74.833399 |
| Pauls Lake | Sullivan | 41.800923 | -74.715263 |
| Pawling Reservoir | Dutchess | 41.575717 | -73.575826 |
| Peach Lake | Putnam | 41.362727 | -73.579199 |
| Peaked Mountain Lake | Herkimer | 43.913588 | -75.003905 |
| Pearl Lake | Sullivan | 41.873108 | -74.763087 |
| Pearsalls Hassock | Nassau | 40.626047 | -73.664256 |
| Peck Lake | Fulton | 43.114988 | -74.413334 |
| Peconic Lake | Suffolk | 40.912322 | -72.723934 |
| Pelham Lake | Westchester | 40.913199 | -73.813727 |
| Pell Lake | Dutchess | 41.658349 | -73.628747 |
| Penniman Cove | Suffolk | 40.824944 | -72.582361 |
| Pepacton Reservoir | Delaware | 42.093877 | -74.847459 |
| Peterson Lake | Steuben | 42.316088 | -77.186363 |
| Pharoah Lake | Essex | 43.805388 | -73.636982 |
| Philmont Reservoir | Columbia | 42.242561 | -73.605447 |
| Pickup Lake | Cattaraugus | 42.112226 | -78.991251 |
| Pico Lake | Herkimer | 43.662655 | -74.862011 |
| Pigeon Lake | Hamilton | 43.846999 | -74.760579 |
| Pillsbury Lake | Hamilton | 43.596668 | -74.534344 |
| Pine Bush Lake | Ulster | 41.612020 | -74.353736 |
| Pine Grove Lake | Rockland | 41.159545 | -74.176440 |
| Pine Kill | Sullivan | 41.622027 | -74.620719 |
| Pine Lakes | Hamilton | 43.537632 | -74.315089 |
| Pine Marsh | Nassau | 40.622802 | -73.572522 |
| Pine Meadow Lake | Rockland | 41.173330 | -74.126051 |
| Pipes Cove | Suffolk | 41.082851 | -72.379279 |
| Piseco Lake | Hamilton | 43.417240 | -74.552279 |
| Piseco Outlet | Hamilton | 43.365314 | -74.527368 |
| Pleasure Lake | Sullivan | 41.697271 | -74.628625 |
| Plum Brook | St. Lawrence | 44.795603 | -74.917809 |
| Pocantico Lake | Westchester | 41.117263 | -73.837366 |
| Poor Lake | Hamilton | 43.564801 | -74.702734 |
| Port Jefferson Harbo | Suffolk | 40.962538 | -73.071366 |
| Port Reservoir | Fulton | 43.087053 | -74.358262 |
| Portaferry Lake | St. Lawrence | 44.227289 | -75.197196 |
| Post Bar Hassock | Nassau | 40.608004 | -73.692975 |
| Potague Lake | Rockland | 41.137795 | -74.212391 |
| Potic Reservoir | Greene | 42.334353 | -73.918899 |
| Potunk Pnt | Suffolk | 40.798851 | -72.647236 |
| Powells Cove | Queens | 40.792481 | -73.831815 |
| Prairie Lake | Fulton | 43.178478 | -74.473899 |
| Prison Reservoir | Dutchess | 41.612589 | -73.661524 |
| Prospect Lake | Orange | 41.456405 | -74.637108 |
| Prospect Park Lake | Kings | 40.656760 | -73.967510 |
| Puddle Hole | Hamilton | 43.592745 | -74.551954 |
| Punch Bowl Lake | Schuyler | 42.369597 | -76.900903 |
| Putnam Lake | Putnam | 41.467771 | -73.540573 |
| Pyramid Lake | Essex | 43.867301 | -73.647639 |